Archived ChiroWatch page (file dated January 4, 1999). Some outside links may no longer work.
Battle of the Kitchener-Waterloo chiros
Sherman vs. Winchester
In a response to the attack by Jeff Winchester on the medical and pharmaceutical industry, this brave Kitchener area chiropractor dukes it out in the newspaper. Unfortunately for the "type-setter", the letter to the editor was titled:
MD didn't speak for profession -
(We all know that the "M.D." should have been "D.C.".)
I read with disbelief a Dec. 29th letter to the editor, written by a Waterloo chiropractor. The article was concerning drug company propaganda an dhis opinions concerning vaccination.
His opinions do not represent the feelings of all chiropractors.
One important issue to address in this case is scope of practice. The issue of vaccination does not fall within the scope of practice of chiropractors. As a primary care health care professional, it is mandatory that we be able to diagnose or at least recognize a wide variety of health concerns from cancer to dermatological disease, and that appropriate referral follow.
It is also important to understand medical procedures and be able to discuss these with our patients for their benefit.
It is not within my scope of practice to denounce certain medical procedures, particularly with a public statement. Are we to believe that the Toronto Hospital for Sick Children and various other institutions are reommending vaccinations to fulfill some secret agenda?
Are we to believe that a Waterloo chiropractor is an authority on vaccination?
Everyone is entitled to an opinion. When given in the media, this opinion is often taken to be the opinion of a profession, which it is not.
ChiroWatch Backlash
Dr. Daryl Sherman should get a gold medal for courage. He should also speak with his colleagues in the K-W Chiropractic Association about Jeff Winchester who remains an embarrassment to not only his profession, but to his community as well.
Did any K-W area chiropractor complain about Jeff Winchester about his meningitis sign in 1997?
Did anyone in that profession ask David E. Reinhardt, the chiropractor for the Good Life Club in Kitchener's Market Square location who had the nerve to place on the door of his office that indicated that he might be a sports physician, not a chiropractor?
Did anyone complain about Jennifer Heick who manipulates animals, without the supervision or direction of a Veterinary doctor?
What the hell is wrong with the chiropractic community in K-W?
Are they too busy to care about their fellow professionals?
We call on all K-W chiropractors to wake up. We ask that in order for them to preserve their professional reputation that they (like my grandmother used to say), should basically shit or get off the pot.
Blow the whistle on crooked practitioners before they eat a big hole into the the shrinking pot that is OHIP. Return the chiropractic profession to a caring profession rather than one that is stuck on the trail to self-destruction.
The exchange as it ran in the Record
Dated pages of the Waterloo Region Record (Kitchener, Ontario), checked against the newspaper page images. Quoted points are what each writer said, not ChiroWatch's findings.
- December 23, 1997, p. 11. Steve Cannon, Record staff: “Meningitis shot is not healthy, Waterloo chiropractor protests.” Jeff Winchester planned to stand outside a school vaccination clinic with a sign; Dr. Doug Sider, associate medical officer of health, answered him; chiropractor James Gregg is quoted as agreeing with Winchester. Page image
- December 29, 1998, p. 10. “Drug companies lie,” letter signed Dr. Jeff Winchester, Chiropractor, Waterloo. Page image
- January 4, 1999, p. 6. “MD didn’t speak for profession,” letter signed Dr. Daryl Sherman, Chiropractor, Waterloo, replying to Winchester’s December 29 letter. The headline gave the writer the wrong title; Gerald Zettler’s letter of January 20 says the mistake prompted a reply from Dr. Robert English, MD. Page image
- January 7, 1999, p. 8. Letter from Antoinette Hilliard, Waterloo, hoping Winchester is as thankful as she is that children are vaccinated. Page image
- January 8, 1999, p. 10. Letter from Dr. Robert English, Family Physician, Fergus. He writes that chiropractors may call themselves doctors but are not MDs, that the Record’s staff, not the chiropractor, wrote the “MD” headline, and that he can “promise” every MD who read the page was deeply offended. His letter does not discuss vaccination. Page image
- January 12, 1999, p. 6. “Vaccines can kill,” letter signed Dr. James Gregg, DC, Waterloo, supporting Winchester. Page image
- January 20, 1999, p. 6. “Vaccines are the wise choice,” by Dr. Douglas C. Kittle, MD, Director and Medical Officer of Health, Wellington-Dufferin-Guelph Health Unit; and “Confusion of letters,” by Gerald Zettler, Kitchener, who names Sherman as the January 4 writer and says the Record’s mistake prompted a reply from Dr. Robert English, MD (January 8, above). Page image
- January 28, 1999, p. 10. “Chiropractic training doesn’t include immunization expertise,” Second Opinion by Dr. Vincent Leering, a chiropractor in private practice in Waterloo. He writes that neither Gregg nor Winchester has a formal background that qualifies him as an immunization expert, and that their views are not reflective of all chiropractors. Page image
- February 4, 1999, p. 10. “Views are their own,” letter from Dr. Robert B. Miller, DC, President, Waterloo Regional Chiropractic Society. He writes that Winchester and Gregg are not currently members of the Society and that their vaccination opinions do not speak for any recognized group within the profession. Page image
Page images are on Newspapers.com; a subscription may be needed to view them.
- Jeff Winchester: Drug companies lieThe December 29, 1998 letter.
- Meningitis shot is not healthy, Waterloo chiropractor protestsKitchener-Waterloo Record, December 23, 1997.
- The Chiropractic War on Public HealthThe main ChiroWatch page on anti-vaccine chiropractors.
- How to file a complaintWith the regulator and the other agencies.
- Chiropractors and Children
- QuackeryWatch: NDs, chiropractors and homeopaths on vaccinesWhat alternative practitioners may and may not say about vaccines.
- QuackeryWatch: the Anti-Vax Rap SheetWho has been charged or disciplined, and the penalties.