Saved copy of a National Post article by Brad Evenson, December 4, 2000, kept for reference. Copyright remains with the publisher.
Ilya Paraskova's throat began to hurt three days after his cousin's birthday party. He would cry when he swallowed. That night, he spiked a fever. Multiplying on the surface of Ilya's throat, a deadly germ was choking off the 3-year-old's air supply.
"His heart was racing," recalls his mother, Irina. "I counted 120, 130 beats. Like a bird."
She could not fail to recognize his symptoms. The TV news in Moscow had given nightly updates on Russia's diphtheria outbreak -- the largest in 50 years.
Ten days later, a grey sheet of dead blood cells, pus and bacteria called a pseudomembrane formed along Ilya's tonsils, choking his airways. Worse, the diphtheria germs had begun to secrete a toxin into his blood, slowly destroying his nerves and heart. He died suddenly a few days later, on Sept. 5, 1995. "The doctors say he had a heart attack," says Irina. "His arms and legs were blue."
Now living in Ontario, Irina -- who married a Canadian businessman in 1997 and has a one-year-old baby daughter -- vows she will not lose another child to a preventable disease. "Even in Russia, there was [diphtheria] vaccine," she says. "But people said it was bad. Maybe it was. I don't know. They said maybe it could make your babies sick. So I did not give Ilya this vaccine. A terrible mistake."
Few Canadians have seen the horrors of diphtheria, rubella or polio because of routine childhood immunization. Yet each year, roughly 34,000 children under the age of four do not get vaccinated.
Some parents object to vaccination on religious or philosophical grounds. Others are swayed by claims that the cure is worse than the disease. One increasingly popular theory is that vaccines may be linked to the growing number of neurological and autoimmune diseases that have been diagnosed over the last 20 years. Even those who vaccinate their kids have hard questions for their doctors.
"People want to know more about the risks and benefits of vaccination than ever before," says Dr. Arlene King, acting chief of immunization with Health Canada.
Health providers are among the detractors. A Quebec survey to be presented at the Canadian National Immunization Conference this week in Halifax suggests many nurses and some doctors have only lukewarm confidence in vaccines. "Nurses are more guarded than physicians," says King, noting that only 59% of Quebec nurses polled considered vaccines safe, effective and useful, compared to 90% of doctors.
This is ironic, given that vaccination is hailed by most experts as one of medicine's great success stories. Discovered in the 1800s by an English surgeon, Dr. Edward Jenner, vaccination works by "priming" the immune system with a mild or disabled form of bacterium or virus so the body will recognize and attack such invaders in the future. The first vaccine, against smallpox, wiped out the disease around the world. Polio vaccine has done much the same.
Today, children routinely get 37 doses of 11 different vaccines, ranging from mumps to tetanus. Many doctors add chicken pox vaccine to the mix. Parents wonder if so many shots are necessary to prevent diseases they had themselves as children.
"Who needs a needle for chicken pox?" says Mildred Henderson, a Winnipeg mother of four boys. "We've all had it. Remember chicken pox parties? One kid would get it so you'd invite the whole neighbourhood so everyone could get it over with."
But doctors who see the complications of such "routine" childhood illnesses have a different view.
"It used to be that everybody back in the 1950s and 1960s got measles, and most people say, 'I had measles and I did fine,' " says Dr. Scott Halperin, a professor of pediatrics at Dalhousie University.
"But if you look at the statistics, in the range of 4% to 5% of people who get measles will get pneumonia, severe enough to be hospitalized. And if you think of 350,000 or so cases of measles over a period of years, then you're talking about a substantial numbers of cases of pneumonia."
Worse, one in 1,000 people who get measles suffers a serious brain infection called encephalitis. So does one in 400 people with mumps, and one in 1,000 who get chickenpox. These infections can lead to permanent brain or nerve damage, including deafness and facial paralysis. Some cases are fatal.
While diseases like diphtheria and polio have all but disappeared in Canada, they can return quickly. "Disease knows no borders," says King.
For example, visitors to Canada caused outbreaks of measles recently in religious communities in Alberta and Quebec. In Manitoba, a rubella (German measles) outbreak occurred in 1997, with cases rising to 3,991 from 237 in 1996. The disease is particularly serious for pregnant women because it causes brain damage in fetuses. In British Columbia, rave parties were blamed for an outbreak of mumps among young adults in 1997.
King stresses that vaccines protect more than the individual child getting the needle. There are children who have egg allergies or other conditions and cannot tolerate certain vaccines (some vaccines are grown in an egg medium). And vaccines only work about 85% to 90% of the time. So if one infected child brings measles into a school, up to 15% of vaccinated students and the sprinkling of those who cannot be vaccinated could get infected.
"We have a responsibility, in my opinion, to provide a protective cushion around those individuals by having as many people around them immunized as possible -- we call that herd immunity," says King.
According to immunization experts, most side effects to vaccines are no more serious than a sore arm or mild fever, which can be controlled by taking acetaminophen before or after the shot. But in a few cases -- ranging from one in 1,000 to one in a million -- children suffer a more serious problem. This can include hypo- or hypersensitivy, which are forms of allergic reactions, and even anaphylactic shock.
"Vaccines are never going to be 100% safe," says King. "There will always be some small risk involved. But what we're saying is, the risk is a fraction of what you'd face with the infectious diseases you're vaccinating against."
Historically, vaccines were deliberately made from substances that cause disease. For example, early typhoid vaccine was made from the excrement of typhoid patients. Pertussis (whooping cough) vaccine came from the mucous of infected children. These crude extracts contained the bacterial cells or toxins that triggered an immune response, but they also contained impurities that caused serious side effects, including fatal allergic reactions. And some versions of polio vaccine in the 1960s were tainted with cancer cells.
Today, advances in cell biology have made vaccines that are much "cleaner" and safer. "We can now slice a bacterium or virus apart, putting only the protective bits into vaccines, and discard the rest," says Dr. Luis Barreto, a senior official with Pasteur Mérieux Connaught, the vaccine manufacturer.
What about mercury? Thimerosal, a preservative containing mercury, helps prevent bacterial contamination when a vaccine vial is opened. But virtually none of the vaccines sold for infants in Canada, including Pentacel, the most widely used, contain any mercury at all.
Many parents also worry that a child's immature immune system can be overwhelmed by being bombarded with so many vaccines. This concern is sharply dismissed by experts. "We are bombarded with thousands and millions of foreign antigens every day of our lives and we're coping with those just fine," says King.
Numerous studies have shown that giving combinations of vaccines at the same time is not only safe, it may be more practical, since it means fewer visits to a doctor's office. Doctors don't like giving multiple shots because children cry or scream blue murder at the prospect of a second needle.
If vaccines are so safe, why are so many people skeptical? The backlash against immunization began in Britain and the United States, initiated by a handful of critics who say vaccines damaged their children.
One of the most prominent is Barbara Loe Fisher, a U.S. mother whose oldest son was a bright, precocious infant until he got his fourth diphtheria-pertussis-tetanus (DPT) shot at 18 months. Since then, the boy has struggled with neurological problems, she says. The experience prompted Loe Fisher to found the U.S.-based National Vaccine Information Center, now a powerful voice among vaccine skeptics.
"What we're having here in this country is control of childhood infectious diseases but [also] an explosion of chronic disease and disability," she says. "Our special-education classrooms are filled with children with brain and immune-system damage. In the last two decades we've had a doubling of learning disabilities, a doubling of AD/HD, a doubling of asthma, a tripling of diabetes, and autism now affects one in 150 children. What we're saying is that science and medicine have not given us an adequate explanation; in fact, they've given us no explanation as to what's happening to our children. What we're saying is, let's examine what we do to every child. And vaccination is one of those things, in ever-increasing numbers and doses."
Loe Fisher's organization is pushing for biological studies that examine the effects of vaccines on children's brains, which develop quickly during the first three years of life -- the period when most kids get all their shots. "We think that there may be genetic differences between children and their responses to vaccines," she says. "So what we're criticizing is the one-size-fits-all approach with vaccines."
Perhaps the best known theory of this kind comes from a British report linking autism to the measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccine. The 1998 case study of 12 infants suggested the MMR vaccine causes irritable bowel syndrome, which is linked to autism. The article, published in the British medical journal The Lancet, caused worldwide headlines.
Subsequent population studies in England and elsewhere have shown no big increase in the rate of autism since the MMR vaccine was introduced in 1988, but the damage in perception may take years to dispel.
"Anyone can make an allegation," says Halperin, who co-ordinates a Canadian program that monitors the adverse effects of vaccines. "It takes a long time to prove it's not true."
Halperin says most children are diagnosed with autism at 12 to 14 months, the age when they normally learn to speak. Coincidentally, it's also the age they get the MMR vaccination. "Parents have a child with autism, and they want to know why," Halperin says. "They link it to vaccination as a possible cause."
While public health officials find the vaccine critics a bother, such groups have been catalysts for vaccine improvements. Today, the National Vaccine Information Center and its allies are credited with helping to accelerate the development of a new form of pertussis vaccine, engineered to cause fewer side effects.
Since the Canadian introduction of this new vaccine in 1997, Halperin said pediatric hospitals report an 80% drop in the rate of febrile seizures after an inoculation, a huge improvement over the old formula. Ironically for the critics, these safety improvements will lead to more vaccines, since safer products mean their benefits outweigh the potential dangers.
"We are going to see vaccines for many more diseases," predicts King.
- The Chiropractic War on Public HealthThe main ChiroWatch page on anti-vaccine chiropractors.
- How to file a complaintWith the regulator and the other agencies.
- Chiropractors and Children
- QuackeryWatch: NDs, chiropractors and homeopaths on vaccinesWhat alternative practitioners may and may not say about vaccines.
- QuackeryWatch: the Anti-Vax Rap SheetWho has been charged or disciplined, and the penalties.