Archived ChiroWatch page, first posted in 2000 (letter dated October 26, 2000). Some outside links may no longer work.
"Ask about vaccination"
Mark C. Mitchell's letter to the editor
Kitchener-Waterloo Record - October 26, 2000.
I have taken the liberty to reorganize theseries of questions so that people can respond to his positions bynumber. I am not responsible for repeating any typos or grammaticalerrors that may have been in the original letter to the editor.
Every year at this time the issue of vaccination seems to become prominent. Here are some questions to ask yourself or your doctor about vaccination:
- Are vaccinated children healthier than unvaccinated children?
- Do vaccines have any long-term side effects or damage that may not surface for months or years?
- Can vaccines cause cancer or fertilization problems?
- Do vaccines cause SIDS (Sudden Infant Death Syndrome) also known as Crib Death?
- What are the chances that my child may be hurt or killed by avaccine?
- Do the assumed benefits of vaccination outweigh the risks?
- Didn't vaccines get rid of acute infectious childhood diseases?
- Was polio eliminated due to vaccination?
- Was the polio shot given in the 50s and 60s contaminated with monkeyvirus (SV40). Is it causing cancer?
- Are there benefits to a child having acute infectious childhood diseases?
- Are ingredients in vaccines safe?
- Do vaccines affect genetic material?
- Can vaccines we receive today affect our grandchildren or greatgrandchildren?
- Are multiple vaccines safe?
- Is there a conflict of interest in vaccine policy decisions?
Mark C. Mitchell
Cambridge
This is a letter of complaint and a challenge to Cambridge, Ontario chiropractor Mark C. Mitchell who in my humble opinion has stepped across the line in the sand set by the College of Chiropractors of Ontario.
26 October 2000
Dear Mark:
I find it very disturbing that you would feel obligated to write a letter to the editor in today's paper without the paper mentioning the fact that you practice chiropractic in Cambridge, Ontario and are a member of the CAC, the Chiropractic Awareness Council, a Canadian based anti-immunization group.
I am sure that someone will write you to address each and every one of the points that you made. Just in case someone out there would like to respond to those points on a personal level, I am going to be sending your letter to several lists for their response. I am also going to send a copy to the CCO, so that they might see what kind of information is being distributed in public by their licensed chiropractors in Ontario.
Perhaps the recent decision that was made by Elizabeth Witmer, ourOntario Provincial Minister of Health, and my MPP, to immunize all people in this Province with the latest influenza vaccine if they areover age 6 months is really upsetting you.
But, why should a person who is trained to provide health services to Ontario residents not know the answers to the questions that you pose? Certainly they taught you well at a chiropractic college, wherever that was. I assume that they taught you critical thinking, and gave you the ability to decide for your own children about the wisdom of vaccination. They taught you to methodically dissect and validate the finer points of public health methods that are routinely used to reduce morbidity, and mortality in infants, children and adults. Perhaps I am making too much of an assumption.
It would be really nice for someone with a background in epidemiology and infectious disease to be able to sit down with you and your fellow CAC members to educate you in what immunization policies really mean, in both the short and long term. I find it incomprehensible that the teaching staff of any chiropractic college in Canada has failed to educate its graduates to think rationally and scientifically before they spout off at the mouth based on some mantra that they learned from some internet site or movie that they bought from Australia that blames allof the world's problems on vaccines.
If the CAC members care to respond, please circulate this letter to them.
For those who don't know who the members of the CAC are, and where they practice, I have included this URL for all:
If anyone who reads this finds a member in their community, you might like to take this opportunity to visit their offices and ask them personally what they think. And, when you go, be prepared to answer every one of those questions for them, and do it so that their staff also hears the answers.
This letter is just one of a series of efforts of the CAC to dissuade people from taking vaccines. A prime example that I vividly recall is when one of their Waterloo members picketed outside Bluevale Collegiate Institute during a meningococcal meningitis epidemic that killed 2 young teenage girls. He told folks that it was not necessary to get the shot.
Chiropractors who attack public health
Another CAC member from Guelph told me that I was a "monkey pus injector". Someone else told me that I was a "skull smashing baby killer".
What is the CAC?
- CAC advocates the early treatment of infants
- CAC lays the blame on the medical profession for many deaths
- CAC names Tylenol as a major killer
- CAC is not recognized by the College of Chiropractors of Ontario
Non-CAC chiropractors who oppose vaccination programs
- Colette Szalay - Peterborough columnist - She treads on thin ice when she quotes from unsubstantiated studies and wild claims of people like Viera Scheibner who likes to travel to places where meningitis outbreaks occur and to appear at conferences to claim that the shots aimed to protect people, actually meningitis. What utter rubbish!!!
What does the College of Chiropractor of Ontario have to say?
Ethical Chiropractors shall:
2. Comply with all governing legislation (with ongoing attention given to current requirements under the Regulated Health Professions Act, 1991, as amended, Chiropractic Act, 1991, Healing Arts Radiation Protection Act, and the regulations under those acts).
3. Endeavour to improve the standards of chiropractic services within the community.
DESCRIPTION OF POLICY
2. In disseminating information about immunization to patients or to members of the public, members shall:
b. outline, within the member's knowledge and expertise, the effects, benefits, risks and side-effects of immunization, versus no immunization for: individual patients and the public at large; and
c. advise that the Immunization of School Pupils Act provides for circumstances in which school pupils may be exempted from immunization.
Public health efforts opposed by the CAC
I wonder if the CCO executive board would again like to take the opportunity to address the public on the issues of chiropractors who advocate against public health efforts in Ontario.- Flu vaccine facts - Ontario Ministry of Health
- Waterloo Regional Health Unit where you can download the .pdf files about influenza vaccine and children
- Ontario Health Units
- County Vaccine programs
- World Health Org. page on vaccines
- Bill and Melinda Gate's vaccine page
Warning to those who yell fire in a theatre
Anyone who sees or hears of a licensed chiropractor, dentist, or medical doctor who speaks out, writes letters, appears in the media to bash medical efforts of local health authorities to protect our loved ones from infectious disease has a responsibility to contact their local medical officer of health and the regulatory body for that profession.Elizabeth Witmer, our Minister of Health is taking a very responsible position here, and any healthcare professional who advocates against those efforts should be the subject of an investigation for that. To yell fire in a crowded theatre is a serious breech of the criminal code, and for anyone to advise against an immunization based on false information is not just treading on thin ice.
- ChiroWatch responds to the Mitchell letterThe companion response page.
- The Chiropractic War on Public HealthThe main ChiroWatch page on anti-vaccine chiropractors.
- How to file a complaintWith the regulator and the other agencies.
- Chiropractors and Children
- QuackeryWatch: NDs, chiropractors and homeopaths on vaccinesWhat alternative practitioners may and may not say about vaccines.
- QuackeryWatch: the Anti-Vax Rap SheetWho has been charged or disciplined, and the penalties.