Archived ChiroWatch page, first posted in 2000 (file dated October 28, 2000). Some outside links may no longer work.
On October 26, 2000 the Record published another anti-vaccine rant by a local personality. However they failed to identify Mark Mitchell as a chiropractor.The importance of this error or omission is right in line with the pronouncements by some area chiropractor on the subject of vital public health issues.
While Mitchell represents a fringe group of chiropractors, the Chiropractic Awaremess Council, the failure of the local chiropractic association to control this group's point of view is shameful.
A few years ago, one of the CAC cohorts appeared front row centre on radio, TV and in the Record to flaunt the bizarre anti-vaccine ravings during a meningococcal meningitis epidemic. Just think of it for a minute. Suppose one of your doctors stood up at the gates of your child's high school during a week of funerals and panic caused by a terrible plague of meningitis. Suppose the Chief Coroner of Ontario called up the College of Physicians to complain about it, threatening to pull their medical license of the doctor who did this. Suppose that this doctor continued to do it, year after year.
Well, that was the likely scenario of what happened to a CAC chiropractor in 1997-8 during the meningitis outbreak. But it was the Chiropractic College of Ontario, not the CPSO that allowed this license holder to continue their anti-vaccine activities, and they did nothing to control the misinformation campaign of any of the other CAC members.
I ask the citizens of Waterloo Region to back the efforts of our public health workers and our medical and nursing staff to insure that our children and family members receive the right information. It's really unfortunate that the Record allowed this letter to appear without checking its authenticity as far as the long list of questions that was tabled by Mitchell.
I could go through that long list one by one to refute almost every one of them. Instead I invite chiropractors who support immunizations to write in to the Record and explain to the public why members of their profession continue to lie to the public about vaccines. Why is the College of Chiropractors of Ontario not sanctioning any of the CAC members who live in Ontario?
If I was a medical researcher and if I fudged data, or lied to patients who were to receive a potentially life-saving vaccine or medication, I would not only be faced with a disciplinary hearing, I might be thrown in jail.
Why is this any different with chiropractic fringe groups? The chances are that these anti-vax proponents have had little or no training in microbiology, virology, or in medical ethics. The chances are that most of them have received heavy indoctrination of chiropractic philosophy at weekend meetings in hotels sponsored by lobbying groups from the States. Some of them probably show a video tape that is full of nothing but lies about the safety of vaccines, the origins of AIDS, and why newborn babies owe all of their problems to a wrongful birth or delivery at the hands of medical doctors.
Anyone has the right to believe in alternative medicine for themselves, but the CAC has no right to lie to the public, to foment hate, and to spread fear amongst our own patients. That is grounds for not only civil lawsuits for interfering in our practices, but it also might be grounds for criminal charges should any of these children be denied vaccines because some chiropractor, or naturopathic fringe group convinced our patients that they should avoid immunizations.
I would like to see legislation in place to protect our patients from attacks on their health by licensed health care profesionals. Letters written by CAC members are a prime example why CMCC, the Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College graduates must take an oath to protect their patients from false information. It should be part of their code of ethics.
Last weekend the Waterloo Chiropractic association invaded the Waterloo County Board of Education to deliver their story to teachers and others at their annual Wellness Fair. It would have been an excellent place to display their pro-immunization position. Somehow, I think I missed it.For those who don't know who the members of the CAC are, and where they practice, I have included this URL for all:
If anyone who reads this finds a member in their community, you might like to take this opportunity to visit their offices and ask them personally what they think. And, when you go, be prepared to answer every one of those questions for them, and do it so that their staff also hears the answers.
This letter is just one of a series of efforts of the CAC to dissuade people from taking vaccines. A prime example that I vividly recall is when one of their Waterloo members picketed outside Bluevale Collegiate Institute during a meningococcal meningitis epidemic that killed 2 young teenage girls. He told folks that it was not necessary to get the shot.
CAC members attack public health
- Meningitis hotline
- Chiro's story on Dec. 23, 1997
- a year later he was in rare but familiar form again.
Mark C. Mitchell's letter to the editor
So, here is Dr. Mark C. Mitchell's letter to the editor that appeared in the Kitchener-Waterloo Record on October 26, 2000. I will number the series of questions so that people can respond to your positions by number. I am not responsible for repeating any typos or grammatical errors that may be in the original letter to the editor.
"Ask about vaccination"
Every year at this time the issue of vaccination seems to become prominent. Here are some questions to ask yourself or your doctor about vaccination:- Are vaccinated children healthier than unvaccinated children?
- Do vaccines have any long-term side effects or damage that may not surface for months or years?
- Can vaccines cause cancer or fertilization problems?
- Do vaccines cause SIDS (Sudden Infant Death Syndrome) also known as Crib Death?
- What are the chances that my child may be hurt or killed by a vaccine?
- Do the assumed benefits of vaccination outweigh the risks?
- Didn't vaccines get rid of acute infectious childhood diseases?
- Was polio eliminated due to vaccination?
- Was the polio shot given in the 50s and 60s contaminated with monkey virus (SV40). Is it causing cancer?
- Are there benefits to a child having acute infectious childhood diseases?
- Are ingredients in vaccines safe?
- Do vaccines affect genetic material?
- Can vaccines we receive today affect our grandchildren or great grandchildren?
- Are multiple vaccines safe?
- Is there a conflict of interest in vaccine policy decisions?
Mark C. Mitchell
Cambridge
What is the CAC?
Archives in these links are from 2001 before their web site was changed. The web site was originally known as cac4life.com and is now chiropracticawarenesscouncil.org.- CAC advocates the early treatment of infants
- CAC lays the blame on the medical profession for many deaths
- CAC names Tylenol as a major killer
- CAC was not recognized by the College of Chiropractors of Ontario
Public health efforts opposed by the CAC
I wonder if the CCO executive board would again like to take the opportunity to address the public on the issues of chiropractors who advocate against public health efforts in Ontario.- Flu vaccine facts - Ontario Ministry of Health"
- Regional Health Unit where you can download the .pdf files about influenza vaccine and children
- Immunization & Vaccines Schedules - Canada
- World Health Organization Immunizatin and vaccines
- Bill and Melinda Gate's vaccine page
Warning to those who yell fire in a theatre
Anyone who sees or hears of a licensed chiropractor, dentist, or medical doctor who speaks out, writes letters, appears in the media to bash medical efforts of local health authorities to protect our loved ones from infectious disease has a responsibility to contact their local medical officer of health and the regulatory body for that profession.Elizabeth Witmer, our Minister of Health is taking a very responsible position here, and any healthcare professional who advocates against those efforts should be the subject of an investigation for that. To yell fire in a crowded theatre is a serious breech of the criminal code, and for anyone to advise against an immunization based on false information is not just treading on thin ice.
- Who appointed a CAC chiropractor as the Grand Inquisitor of vaccine?The Mitchell letter with numbered questions.
- The Chiropractic War on Public HealthThe main ChiroWatch page on anti-vaccine chiropractors.
- How to file a complaintWith the regulator and the other agencies.
- Chiropractors and Children
- QuackeryWatch: NDs, chiropractors and homeopaths on vaccinesWhat alternative practitioners may and may not say about vaccines.
- QuackeryWatch: the Anti-Vax Rap SheetWho has been charged or disciplined, and the penalties.