Saved copies of two Kitchener-Waterloo Record items, kept for reference; copyright remains with the publisher. The December 23, 1997 article by Steve Cannon (p. 11) was checked against the newspaper page image on Newspapers.com. The December 27, 1997 editorial (“We can have faith in mass vaccination”) is from the same electronic text archive and has not been checked against a page image. The later letters are listed on Battle of the Kitchener-Waterloo chiros.
> PAPER Kitchener-Waterloo Record > DATE * 971223 > PDATE Tuesday, December 23, 1997 > EDITION Final > SECTION Local > PAGE B1/FRONT > LENGTH 828 words > STOTYPE NEWS > ITYPE COLOUR PHOTO > ILLUS Colour Photo: Peter Lee, Record Staff/ Dr. Jeffrey > * Winchester stands by the sign at his Bridgeport Road chiropractic clinic in Waterloo. > HEADLINE * Meningitis shot is not healthy, Waterloo chiropractor > protests > BYLINE Steve Cannon > SOURCE Record staff > DNOTE Ran with "Clinics" which has been appended to the end of > this story. > CNOTE Picture stored in Library > > A Waterloo chiropractor believes it is unnecessary to > * vaccinate 100,000 young people against meningitis and planned to > take his message to one of the temporary clinics today. > > * Jeffrey Winchester intends to stand outside Bluevale Collegiate > * Institute in Waterloo with a small sign that reads: ``A Meningitis > Shot is not Mandatory'' on one side, and ``Get Informed'' on the > other. > > ``I think all inoculations are dangerous because they mess with the > * body's natural immune system,'' Winchester said Monday. > > But Dr. Doug Sider, Waterloo Region's associate medical officer of > health, said overwhelming medical evidence shows mass vaccinations > are both safe and effective. > > ``He's free to say what he wants and he has said this other > * times,'' Sider said of Winchester. > > ``But the bottom line is when we look at the results of other > community-wide vaccination campaigns . . . the vast number of people > make the decision that this is the course to take.'' > > Jane Daley, the region's director of infectious diseases, said a > similar mass vaccination was effective in wiping out a 1991 > * meningitis outbreak in the Ottawa-Carleton area. > > ``This isn't just the thinking in Waterloo,'' said Daley, who knows > * many chiropractors and naturopaths share Winchester's beliefs. > ``Philosophically, we just have different approaches to disease > control.'' > > James Gregg, another Waterloo chiropractor, would agree with that > statement. > > * Like Winchester, he thinks the mass immunization program is > unnecessary and people don't know enough about the vaccine. > > * Gregg said certain people are susceptible to meningitis. Among them > are alcoholics, people with diabetes, AIDS patients and others with > weakened immune systems, and people who have suffered recent head > traumas. > > ``Those are high-risk people, yeah, I can see that's an issue,'' > Gregg said. ``But a mass vaccination program isn't needed.'' > > Temporary vaccination clinics are being run at six area high > * schools after four people contracted the same strain of meningitis > earlier this month. > > A 16-year-old Kitchener girl died of the disease two weeks before > the others were diagnosed, but there have been no new cases in the > last week. > > * Both Gregg and Winchester believe public health officials have > public safety in mind and are doing what they believe is right. > > * They just disagree with their methods to the point where Winchester > will not allow his own children, ages three and four, to be > vaccinated. > > * Winchester has trouble with inoculations that inject dead bacteria > into the body, which is supposed to react as if the bacteria are > alive and produce antibodies to attack it. > > ``But it's like me bringing a tiger into your office. A live tiger > is going to illicit a different response than a dead tiger, isn't > it? > > ``So, if your body is injected with something that is dead, I look > at the body as being very intelligent and it's not going to react > the way they would like it to.'' > > * Daley said the meningitis vaccine does contain ``killed bacteria.'' > But studies have shown it does spark the immune system into making > antibodies, which is the goal. > > The vaccine takes 10 to 14 days to become effective, and provides > immunity to 85 per cent of those who receive it. > > * Still, Winchester believes salvation does not come from the tip of > a needle, but from healthy living, which will fight off bacteria by > itself, he said. > > * Winchester recognizes many young people don't always eat well. They > might smoke, be generally rundown and ill-equipped to battle > disease. > > ``But there's not 100,000 of them out there, so I want parents to > make a responsible decision,'' he said. ``If they know their kids > are eating right and if their kids are controlling themselves, in my > opinion they don't need this injection.'' > > Sider said he wouldn't gamble. > > * ``I can't stop Jeff Winchester from saying those things, or > believing what he wants to believe,'' Sider said. ``But the proof is > in the pudding. The end result is these community immunization > initiatives do work and the vast majority of people are aware of > that.'' > > Clinics > > * Meningitis vaccination clinics scheduled for today and Wednesday: > > Clinics are only for people aged 12 to 22 who live, work or go to > school in Kitchener, Waterloo or the townships of Wilmot, Woolwich > or Wellesley. People are asked to bring identification to confirm > age and address. Students should also bring their Ontario health > cards. > > Young adults not in school may attend any clinic on any date. > > All clinics run from 9 a.m. to 9 p.m., except for the clinic on, > Dec. 24, which runs from 9 a.m. to 3 p.m.: > > Today: Eastwood for students from Margaret Ave., Courtland Ave., > St. Patrick, St. Bernadette, St. Boniface (Kitchener), St. Joseph > (Kitchener), St. John (Kitchener) and Kitchener students only at > Ecole Secondaire Pere-Rene-de-Galinee; Grand River for students from > Cameron Heights; Bluevale for students from Waterloo Collegiate; > Resurrection for students from Laurentian, Queensmount, Blessed > Sacrament, Our Lady of Grace, Laurentian Christian and Monsignor > Haller. > > Wednesday: Catch-up clinics for all schools, and young adults, at > Eastwood, Grand River, Bluevale and Resurrection. > > There are no clinics Christmas Day or Boxing Day. > DOB 971223 > UPDATE 971223 > > *** END OF DOCUMENT *** > > PAPER Kitchener-Waterloo Record > DATE * 971227 > PDATE Saturday, December 27, 1997 > EDITION Final > SECTION Opinion > PAGE A14 > LENGTH 425 words > STOTYPE EDITORIAL > HEADLINE We can have faith in mass vaccination > SOURCE Kitchener Waterloo Record > > Plague is a word not commonly spoken by Canadians -- and for > good reason. The terror of deadly, contagious diseases spreading > rapidly over wide areas -- which is what a plague is -- grips few of > us because we are shielded by medical science, and in particular its > massive inoculations. > > Smallpox, polio, whooping cough and other illnesses that filled > Canadian graveyards for generations were all defeated in this > country due to public vaccination crusades. > > That record of success should convince every reasonable person that > the vaccination of up to 100,000 young people now going on in > * Waterloo Region is our best defence against a deadly meningitis > outbreak in this area. > > Unfortunately, a few skeptics are stoking public doubt. Waterloo > * chiropractor Jeffrey Winchester opposes the inoculation campaign > * enough to put up a sign that says ``meningitis shot is not mandatory > or necessary.'' He even picketed a vaccination clinic to persuade > people not to have the shot. If he is right that no one legally has > to have the needle, he is wrong, even irresponsible, to call it > needless. > > * And he should be challenged by facts. Meningitis is a dangerous, > swift-moving illness that kills. Four local people contracted the > * same meningitis strain this month. A Kitchener girl died of the > disease two weeks before they were diagnosed. Health officials in > the region studied the situation carefully and made the right > decision that mass vaccination was the best bet to prevent more > sickness and death. > > Canada's medical establishment is neither omnipotent nor > infallible. It can blunder, as it did in the tainted blood scandal > that left thousands of people in the '80s infected with AIDS or > hepatitis. Meanwhile, many people find alternative medical > treatments effective. Chiropractors have their place in promoting > health. But when they claim inoculations are dangerous and interfere > with the body's immune system, they challenge irrefutable science. > > Once one of the world's most dreaded diseases, smallpox killed two > million people in 1967. By 1977, it was declared eradicated. A major > reason this scourge was beaten was massive inoculations. Severe > epidemics of polio, which cripples and kills, swept North America in > the '40s and '50s. But by the '60s it was under control -- again > thanks to vaccination. Vaccines fought whooping cough and > tuberculosis, too. It is also worth recalling that public > * inoculations wiped out a 1991 meningitis outbreak in > Ottawa-Carleton. > > Unless chiropractors, or anyone else, can prove inoculations don't > work, unless that can say how they would thwart an outbreak of > * meningitis and save people, then the life-saving work of local > health officials should continue. > DOB 971227 > UPDATE 971227 > > *** END OF DOCUMENT ***
Related reading
- Back to ChiroWatch: Jeffery Winchester
- More about the meningitis epidemicOn HealthWatcher.net.
- Winchester: “Drug companies lie” (December 29, 1998)The letter that started the 1999 exchange.
- Battle of the Kitchener-Waterloo chirosThe 1999 replies in the Record.
- The Chiropractic War on Public HealthThe main ChiroWatch page on anti-vaccine chiropractors.
- How to file a complaintWith the regulator and the other agencies.
- Chiropractors and Children
- QuackeryWatch: NDs, chiropractors and homeopaths on vaccinesWhat alternative practitioners may and may not say about vaccines.
- QuackeryWatch: the Anti-Vax Rap SheetWho has been charged or disciplined, and the penalties.